Although it is an understandable human reaction, I don't think it's responsible to extrapolate why it's happened, especially suggesting they deserve it. Nobody knows why and asking why won't help find him, nor will using tragedy to hunt for someone or something to blame,
I don't think Aaron is missing because of my family's excommunication of me.
I do not agree with blaming the victim, and I do not make a connection between my excommunication and my missing cousin.
I do not pretend to know why Hashem in His love and wisdom allows painful things to happen to people. I do know that there is almost nothing more painful than being blamed for a difficult and painful situation that one finds oneself in and did not cause. This is a pain I live with daily, and I could never wish it on anyone else.
No one deserves the pain of losing family.
It
is a terrifying and heartbreaking concept to contemplate, let alone
experience. I know that my cousins and the rest of my family are
doing the best they can; and have always been doing the best they can in
dealing with my allegations of child sexual abuse against those they
love. I do not agree with blaming the victim, and I do not make a connection between my excommunication and my missing cousin.
I do not pretend to know why Hashem in His love and wisdom allows painful things to happen to people. I do know that there is almost nothing more painful than being blamed for a difficult and painful situation that one finds oneself in and did not cause. This is a pain I live with daily, and I could never wish it on anyone else.
No one deserves the pain of losing family.
My family did not give me my situation, Hashem did.
I am saying tehillim for my cousin's safe return. My husband is in Jerusalem, as I write this, searching for a cousin he never met, for a family who rejects him.
We are doing these things because we know that only love, and not revenge, can heal pain.
We also know that our cousin's current situation is one that can happen to any of us. This could easily be my child, or your child who is missing. Aaron Sofer is OUR child, OUR brother, no matter who he is related to.
By working on our issues within the community, and by performing acts of baseless love, within the community, we can facilitate healing and mercy.
Please daven for the safe return of Aaron Ben Chulda.